Find A Law Firm

Admissibility of Information Technology tools as Evidence

n Admissibility of Information Technology tools as Evidence

The era of Information technology has brought new methods and modes of commission of crime. Each time a crime is committed whether in physical form or in cyber space, the success of prosecution largely depends on the quality of evidence presented at the trial . With the sophistication in Information technology the weapons of commission of crime are changing thereby posing a serious challenge before the investigation agencies to collect and preserve the evidence. A conviction or acquittal largely depends on the quality of evidence produced by the prosecution.

The advent information technology has brought into existence a new kind of document called the electronic record. This intangible document is of new species has certain uniqueness as compared to conventional form of documents. This document can preserved in same quality and state for a long period of time through encryption processes reducing the chance of tampering of evidence. This document can be in various forms like a simple e-mail or short message or multimedia message or other electronic forms.

The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and Information Technology Act, 2000 grants legal recognition to electronic records and evidence submitted in form of electronic records. According to section 2(t) of the Information Technology Act, 2000 “electronic record” means data, record or data generated, image or sound stored, received or sent in an electronic form or micro film or computer generated micro fiche. The Act recognizes electronic record in a wide sense thereby including electronic data in any form such as videos or voice messages. The Information technology has made it easy to communicate and transmit data in various forms from a simple personal computer or a mobile phone or other kinds of devices. The Information Technology Amendment Act, 2008 has recognized various forms of communication devices and defines a “communicationdevice” under section 2 (ha)of the Act “communication device” means cell phones, personal digital assistance or combination of both or any other device used to communicate, send or transmit any text, video, audio or image. The Indian IT Act 2000 lays down a blanket permission for records not to be denied legal effect if they are in electronic form as long as they are accessible for future reference.

The Act amends the definition of ‘Evidence’in s 3, the interpretation clause of the Indian Evidence Act 1872, to state:


‘Evidence’ means and includes
1)
……
2)
All documents including electronic records produced for the inspection of the Court

Further, in s 4, the IT Act 2000 provides:

Section                                                                                                                                      4
Legal Recognition of electronic records.—Where any law provides that information or any other matter shall be in writing or in the typewritten or printed form, then, notwithstanding anything contained in such law, such requirement shall be deemed to have been satisfied if such information or matter is-

a) rendered made available in an electronic form; and

b) accessible so as to be usable for a subsequent reference.

The evidentiary value of an electronic record totally depends upon its quality. The Indian Evidence Act, 1872 has widely dealt with the evidentiary value of the electronic records. According to section 3 of the Act, “evidence” means and includes all documents including electronic records produced for the inspection of the court and such documents are called documentary evidence. Thus the section clarifies that documentary evidence can be in the form of electronic record and stands at par with conventional form of documents.

The evidentiary value of electronic records is widely discussed under section 65A and 65B of the Evidence Act, 1872. The sections provide that if the four conditions listed are satisfied any information contained in an electronic record which is printed on paper, stored, recorded or copied in an optical or magnetic media, produced by a computer is deemed to be a document and becomes admissible in proceedings without further proof or production of the original, as evidence of any contacts of the original or any facts stated therein, which direct evidence would be admissible.

The four conditions referred to above are:

(1) The computer output containing such information should have been produced by the computer during the period when the computer was used regularly to store or process information for the purpose of any activities regularly carried on during that period by the person having lawful control over the use of the computer.

(2) During such period, information of the kind contained in the electronic record was regularly fed into the computer in the ordinary course of such activities.

(3) Throughout the material part of such period, the computer must have been operating properly. In case the computer was not properly operating during such period, it must be shown that this did not affect the electronic record or the accuracy of the contents.
.

(4) The information contained in the electronic record should be such as reproduces or is derived from such information fed into the computer in the ordinary course of such activities

It is further provided that where in any proceedings, evidence of an electronic record is to be given , a certificate containing the particulars prescribed by 65B of the Act, and signed by a person occupying a responsible official position in relation to the operation of the relevant device or the management of the relevant activities would be sufficient evidence of the matters stated in the certificate.

The apex court in State v Navjot Sandhu while examining the provisions of newly added s 65B, held that in a given case, it may be that the certificate containing the details in sub- s 4 of s 65B is not filed, but that does not mean that secondary evidence cannot be given. It was held by the court that the law permits such evidence to be given in the circumstances mentioned in the relevant provisions, namely, ss 63 and 65 of the Indian Evidence Act 1872. Paragraph 150 of the judgment which is apposite, reads as under:

150. According to Section 63, secondary evidence means and includes, among other things, “copies made from the original by mechanical processes which in themselves insure the accuracy of the copy, and copies compared with such copies.

Section 65 enables secondary evidence of the contents of a document to be adduced if the original is of such a nature as not to be easily movable. Hence, printouts taken from the computers/servers by mechanical process and certified by a responsible official of the service-providing company can be led in evidence through a witness who can identify the signatures of the certifying officer or otherwise speak of the facts based on his personal knowledge. Irrespective of the compliance with the requirements of s 65-B, which is a provision dealing with admissibility of electronic records, there is no bar to adducing secondary evidence under the other provisions of the Indian Evidence Act 1872, namely, ss 63 and 65.


It is pertinent to note herein a recent development, that as per the IT Amendment Bill 2008 (passed by both houses of Indian Parliament and yet to be enforced), s 79A empowers the Central Government to appoint any department, body or agency as examiner of electronic evidence for providing expert opinion on electronic form evidence before any court or authority. ‘Electronic form of evidence’ herein means any information of probative value that is either stored or transmitted in electronic form and includes computer evidence, digital, audio, digital video, cellphones, digital fax machines.

Further as per Section 85 B of the Indian Evidence Act, there is a presumption as to authenticity of electronic records in case of secure electronic records ( i.e records digitally signed as per Section 14 of the IT Act,2000. Other electronic records can be proved by adducing evidence and presumption will not operate in case of documents which do not fall under the definition of secure electronic records. It is pertinent to point out herein that with the passage of the Information Technology Amendment Act 2008, India would become technologically neutral due to adoption of electronic signatures as a legally valid mode of executing signatures. This includes digital signatures as one of the modes of signatures and is far broader in ambit covering biometrics and other new forms of creating electronic signatures.

The position of electronic documents in the form of SMS, MMS and E-mail in India is well demonstrated under the law and the interpretation provided in various cases. In State of Delhi v. Mohd. Afzal & Others, it was held that electronic records are admissible as evidence. If someone challenges the accuracy of a computer evidence or electronic record on the grounds of misuse of system or operating failure or interpolation, then the person challenging it must prove the same beyond reasonable doubt. The court observed that mere theoretical and general apprehensions cannot make clear evidence defective and in admissible. This case has well demonstrated the admissibility of electronic evidence in various forms in Indian courts.

The basic principles of equivalence and legal validity of both electronic signatures and hand written signatures and of equivalence between paper document and electronic document has gained universal acceptance. Despite technical measures, there is still probability of electronic records being tampered with and complex scientific methods are being devised to determine the probability of such tampering. For admissibility of electronic records, specific criteria have been made in the Indian Evidence Act to satisfy the prime condition of authenticity or reliability which may be strengthened by means of new techniques of security being introduced by advancing technologies.

(2005) 11 SCC 600.

2003 (3) JCC 1669.

Comments
Sunny January 21, 2012
I'm so glad that the intrneet allows free info like this!
Natashatew February 15, 2012
How to download X-Rumer 7.0.10 ??
Give me URL please!!!
It is the best program for mass posting on forums! XRumer can break most types of captchas!
AlexPlomb June 9, 2012
Earth, important post from Alpha Centauri! 混蛋

你他媽的所有混蛋
你是他媽的愚蠢

tất cả các mẹ ngu ngốc

http://superhueta.ch/

あなたのすべての愚かな馬鹿

你他媽的所有混蛋
你是他媽的愚蠢

สอบถามรายละเอียดการเรียนต่อโทด้านโภชนาการค่ะ
لدي أنبوب منزلك المكسورة
יש לי צינור שבור הבית שלך

I hope you understand me , otherwise the earth will be destroyed
 viren October 15, 2012
Ff
Imre September 8, 2013
The answer of an expter. Good to hear from you.
Andrey September 9, 2013
big ups on the big two... my third anniversary comes up in a coplue of weeks! it only seems like yesterday that we strapped on a keyboard and started riding the surf of the digital divide. i applaud your efforts and pray that you continue to spread THE WORD to the WORLD, my friend!
Andrea September 9, 2013
Monica - Asante sana! I hope to get the BBR up today...Iya - Thank you. Have you considered cirtaeng a blog for yourself? U might be the only 70-year old Black woman with a blog if you do so. That would be great! http://azhnliw.com [url=http://esjtkibco.com]esjtkibco[/url] [link=http://cvnngxdjv.com]cvnngxdjv[/link]
Rkii September 10, 2013
This is a really innlleigett way to answer the question.
Hitesh September 10, 2013
It's a plaseure to find someone who can think so clearly http://dyacshpxw.com [url=http://eerwiz.com]eerwiz[/url] [link=http://djgrursbqkl.com]djgrursbqkl[/link]
Ouldmuh October 16, 2013
Hey, (i speak french) je m'inscrit sur ce forum je me nomme Nacim Ould Kaddour j'habite a Manchester, i m a fan of BRC ( British Rally Championship )

a bientot
gucci bags December 30, 2013
With this, you can lower your cost and spare enough money for other areas of gucci purses the bash It's probable to openly make use of the loan quantity Regardless of whether you choose from Savannah as well as Atlantic City jet charters, you are going to in no way be bored once you to your destination There are several links to any or all varieties of information that's useful to the candidates No wonder several shampoos have red bottom shoes 1 of their components this oil
Once it is extremely simple for a person to shield his cell phone from any kind of damage If you have the bad credit scores, then you have to pay the higher rates of interest on your loans Call the customized items suppliers that expose a torrent of their past works in their websites for gucci bags they will have more credibility and authority To complete this it's great to study the ideas from the Law of Attraction And plastic has got lots of detractors because it is nonbiodegradable
The components are beef, flour or breadcrumbs, pork, garlic and onions, soy sauce, salt, pepper, grape jelly or pineapple You should definitely look into joining an auto club, if Christian Louboutin Outlet you already haven't done so These on the outside also have no probability of getting into the mattressThe secrets to success in the triumph against gum disease and most oral problems are hidden in nature A few of their some other task responsibilities tend to be: inspecting gums and teeth with regard to dentistry abnormalities; getting xrays of tooth; recording patients? Christian Louboutin online teeth's health background; as well as aiding the particular dental office in the course of procedures
This helps consumers find out how the process actually works and what to expect when going through their reading process Almost all of the debt collection agencies I found seemed very secretive about their methods of collection and suggested that they were confined to collections gucci outlet within certain statesI am engaged in carrying out my plan If you are looking for advice regarding business plan writing, you may be overwhelmed by the large amount of overly detailed information you are finding It could be difficult to personally call each and every life insurance business, so checking them out initially online is a great way to dismiss the gucci riffraff and find a couple of serious contenders
Where essential, they are able to also discover the route of outofcourt solutions Se il tuo gestore non li usa, sta omettendo strumenti essenziali al Trading Forex SCIENZA DEL Christian Louboutin outlet online Trading Forex Il Forex If your vehicle will make various stops during a journey and drop off at many points then this lock is easy to use in a hurryThe possible victory associated with an individual's claim depends on the selection of an outstanding lawyer They will wallow in it, awaiting time they can provide a tiny assistance beneath our own biceps once we review, or possibly to produce all of us a lot more at ease even as unwind in regards to the couches after a long night
(Please Enter the code above shown on image)